St. Louis Game Time: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Once A Metro covering Red Bull New York!

Offseason Banter: Winchester vs Stastny

All the talk of Keith Tkachuk Re-Signing soon should spur some additional thought in the minds of Blues fans.

Assuming Tkachuk is back for at least the 09-10 Season, the Blues have the following forwards under contract:
McDonald - Backes - Boyes
Perron - Berglund - Oshie
Kariya - Tkachuk - Steen
Stastny - McClement - ?
King/Janssen

The question mark is that extra 3rd/4th line "grinder". That guy who plays most of the season checking hard, seeing a little special teams play, a role player. Who could fill that role?

The likeliest answer is an internal source. Someone already in the system or a player on last year’s roster who is now a Free Agent. The Blues have BJ Crombeen, Brad Winchester, DJ King, Chris Porter, and Cam Paddock. I am sure I'm missing someone, but those are who come to mind as NHL level fillers who have done this role before.

Before getting too much in to this (and I know the title has told you where I am going), we need a few more assumptions.
1. Blues Re-Sign BJ Crombeen since he is a RFA. Lets just assume 3 years at $900k, $1.0 mil, $1.25mil, totaling $3.15mil which would be a $1.05mil cap hit.
2. The Blues liked the success they had using a larger, more physical line up.
3. Stastny, King, and Janssen are all "up" after the 09-10 season and would be potential targets to lose their roster spot to maintain team size.

You can be pretty sure that King isn’t a target. He has size, can play, fight, and is a RFA after 09-10. Leaving the Blues with Janssen vs. Stastny. Janssen has a clear role to be a fighter and isn’t needed in that many games. Janssen is also a RFA after 09-10, so if the Blues want to keep him, he is a cheaper buy than Stastny (in theory).

Now we are at Winchester vs. Stastny and our question is:

Does the size and production of Winchester equal more of a benefit than Stastny already being under a smaller contract?

Lets take a look at where both players stand in terms of being an asset to the team.

Winchester
Big body to work the boards, corners, and get to the net.
Posses a pretty quick shot.
Willing to hit and take a hit.
Offensive production from the "bottom 6".
Can play on the power play.
Has Playoff experience.

Stastny:
Small, quick skater.
Can play the PK effectively.
Has speed to fore-check.
Could play Center or Wing.
Responsible defensively.

Factors Against Each Player:

Winchester - Tkachuk and Crombeen Re-Signed. AHL depth under contract (Porter, Paddock, etc). UFA and could get bigger contract offers from other teams. Kariya added to power play likely pushes Winchester in to less power play time, therefore reducing his production. Giving a "grinder' a raise and paying him more than someone else who could potentially do the same job for less.

Stastny - Blues have multiple effective penalty killing forwards in McClement, Steen, Oshie, Backes, and Crombeen. Patrik Berglund could also be thrown in to the mix next year. Must pass through waivers go to Peoria. Small size with limited offensive upside.

The wild card is the contract. Stastny is signed, done deal. Winchester would require the Blues to add him, at a higher rate than Stastny, and then move Stastny or Janssen off the roster.  At this point, this is where you "gamble" (I use that term loosely because losing Yan wouldn't destroy the organization) and bring back Winchester at more money and find a way to move down or out Stastny.

There seems to be little doubt that Murray found the right buttons to push Winchester to the next level, to become a better player. Winchester has the size the Blues need to maintain till the team is better equiped to play the "Red Wing style" of quick transition and possession. You cannot win if you don't score and scoring depth is a need in the new NHL. Winchester proving 12-15 or so goals from the bottom 6 is a huge bonus to the team. Certainly those extra goals and physical presence are worth an extra $500,000.

Now this could all be a moot point, Winchester could pass on the Blues offer and go elsewhere. However I think the Blues want his size back and Winchester wants to come back. I think this might be one of the few instances where you reward the "grinder" and give him the raise. Yes, his roster spot can be filled for cheaper, but what he brings back is worth the investment.

Poll
If you were forced to choose between Winchester and Stastny, who would you pick?
Winchester - Big body and can score, better than a smaller Yan.
32 votes
Stastny - He is already under contract, don't need to pay a grinder more.
3 votes
Neither - We got King Kong and Bam Bam to be in the 4th line next year!
12 votes

47 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 7 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Out of curiosity...

… since I get squat for Peoria news down here, how many more years of development does Stastny have ahead of him in the AHL? He was a necessity plug-in this season, but from what I watched of the Blues, Winchester was more productive and a more solid piece.

I could see Winchester filling that void sooner than Stastny, with Crombeen being the 7th man. King might possibly be fodder in a trade for someone’s rights if we have to.

Since the main cog that we need is a back-up goaltender, perhaps King could be used as part of a small salary dump to acquire one, like Sushi from Philly.

Reporter: There`s a "stamp out the Beatles movement" underway in Detroit. What are you going to do about it?

Paul McCartney: We`re going to start a campaign to stamp out Detroit.

by hildymac on Jun 18, 2009 11:46 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I don’t think Yan has much refining left. He signed a 2 year deal last offseason that would turn in to a 1 way deal for 09-10. So its now or never in St Louis most likely. His role is 4th line PK…we got tons of PK players…we coudl use the offense from Winchester IMO.

Never thought about dealing DJ to be honest. I’d rather keep him than Janssen though.

Bleeding Blue blog @ The BlueNote Zone
http://thebluenotezone.wordpress.com

Twitter:
http://twitter.com/thebluenotezone

Rodimus Prime at StlToday and BluesFan 45 elsewhere...

by BluesFan45 on Jun 18, 2009 11:50 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I wasn't sure what Cam's roll as hometown fave has to play with decisions.

We’ve missed King for a year, so he might not be so high in the thoughts and minds of people. I didn’t realize that Yan’s contract was 1 way for this season. That’s an interesting quandry we have for 4th line PK. I’d prefer Winchester to Stastny, but I don’t know what to do with the backup.

Of course, I’d prefer a backup at a position to not having diddly squat in that position.

Reporter: There`s a "stamp out the Beatles movement" underway in Detroit. What are you going to do about it?

Paul McCartney: We`re going to start a campaign to stamp out Detroit.

by hildymac on Jun 18, 2009 11:57 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I’m thinking having Winchester now locked to a two year deal, gives you options…since Steen, Stastny, King, and Janssen are all under contract just through 09-10. Summer of 10 we have to make decisions on them…with Winchester here, he fills the 4th line LW with McClement and Crombeen…then you can worry about picking one of teh two fighters for your “13th Forward” and not be forced in to keeping Steen. Not that I want Alex gone….but I like options.

The Bleeding Blue blog @ The Blue Note Zone

Add Me on Twitter

Rodimus Prime at StlToday and BluesFan 45 elsewhere...

by BluesFan45 on Jun 20, 2009 9:14 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Sounds good to me.

I like having Steen around – he has a real nose for the puck. But I want depth, too, like you said.

I would be scared if we had primary scoring but no one to shut down the other teams’ primary scorers.

Reporter: There`s a "stamp out the Beatles movement" underway in Detroit. What are you going to do about it?

Paul McCartney: We`re going to start a campaign to stamp out Detroit.

by hildymac on Jun 22, 2009 4:44 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

A nose for the puck?

I see what you did there.

by gallagher on Jun 22, 2009 7:13 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Subtle, aren't I?

Reporter: There`s a "stamp out the Beatles movement" underway in Detroit. What are you going to do about it?

Paul McCartney: We`re going to start a campaign to stamp out Detroit.

by hildymac on Jun 23, 2009 5:00 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

You wanna know why? Because sometimes Lunchables are the friggin' bomb, that's why.
Start posting about the Blues »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Img_8686__large__small
NHL Western Conference Playoff Picture, draft
St__louis_rams_helmet_rightface_small
Lines 2010-2011
St_louis_blues_1992_small
NHL10-Leage team UPDATED-AGAIN
Ajw1362_small
Second City Hockey is breaking down...
Alternate_logo_small
Nice Jonas Junland story at AHL.com
Stag_logo_small
03/14 Road Music: @ Minnesota Nor.... Wild
Stag_logo_small
03/13 Road Music: @ Columbus Blue Jackets
Alternate_logo_small
NCAA Men's Hockey page at Facebook
Img000006_small
Hockey Future On Top 10 College Free Agents
Alternate_logo_small
Eller stays hot, but Rivermen fall to Stars

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recommended FanShots

Dayum, Kinger opened The Boogeyman up like a can of tuner.
Backes design from your friends at 314 Threads [314threads.com]. De-troit Sucks.
I got my Inglorious Backes shirt and wearing it proudly =)

Recent FanShots

Incase you missed it in the GDT....

woulda been an epic picture if we had won....
Tales from the Crease - 3/15/10 - The Blues' Kryptonite
Versus and DirecTV reach agreement finally
The Fuck You Doin? Caption Time. 
Via Rutherford's blog (and his photo).
A Young Brain Builds A Winner In St. Louis
new swag coming soon. sadly i gotz like one more game to go to at the sec so limited availablity lol.
Keystone Lake Zamboni falls through thin ice


A Zamboni took a dip in North America's largest groomed skating pond at Keystone Resort tonight.
A driver was grooming the lake at about 6:15 p.m., when the ice cracked and the 7,000-pound machine began to sink at about 6:15 p.m. As a precaution, skaters were cleared from another area of the 5-acre pond, resort spokesman Ryan Whaley said. The driver was not injured.
There was no word immediately on how soon the rink might re-open, but staff will examine the ice and remove the Zamboni Wednesday, Whaley said.
"They'll take it out and we'll see how it is," Whaley said of the machine and the safety of the ice around the crater.
With a lake that large, other areas could reopen immediately, he said.

Once it dries out, the machine is likely salvageable, he said.
Kenneth Waesche snapped a photo of the sunken ice machine when he stopped by Lakeside Village for a pickup game of hockey. His wife planned to do some skating.
Waesche said that the "thin ice" sign in the foreground of the photo was some distance away from where the Zamboni went in.
The lake is typically open from Dec. 18 to March. 28 depending on the weather, from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. 

VIDEO
Watch video of the Keystone zamboni falling through the ice. 
Video courtesy of Robert Brecht.

Read more: http://www.denverpost.com/recommended/ci_14644093#ixzz0hqeeiNLo
I got one too.  I'm hairier and less pretty than Carnie, but it still looks gooood.
KPLR news 1970 with Bob Plager. I don't remember Bob doing the news, I'm guessing he was the sports guy? How long did he have this gig?

+ New FanShot All FanShots >

Featured Poll

Poll
What will Paul Kariya's legacy be in St. Louis?

  34 votes | Results

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo link

An Interview With Sharks Prospect Jamie McGinn

Denver left winger Rhett Rakhshani (9) and Colorado College defenseman Nate Prosser (15) chase the puck into the corner during an NCAA college hockey game in Denver, Friday, March 5, 2010.

2010 Hobey Baker Award Finalists Announced

New Jersey Devils' Patrik Elias, of the Czech Republic, comes out with a green hat on St. Patrick's Day after defeating the Pittsburgh Penguins 5-2 in an NHL hockey game Wednesday, March 17, 2010, in Newark, N.J. Elias was voted the star of the game. (AP Photo/Bill Kostroun)

Devils Complete Regular-Season Sweep Of Penguins With 5-2 Win

More from SBNation.com >


Bill Lumbergh

Face_lo-res_copy_small gallagher

160gthockey_small Brad Lee

Peter Gibbons

Plagerbarc_bob_small Poor College Student

250px-nation_of_joe_small averagejoe

Michael Bolton

Alternate_logo_small Tomorrows Blues

Krispy_kreme_small Donut King

Stag_logo_small CrossCheckRaise

_unset__small hildymac